Over the last several years three prestigious organizations, The Society of American Magicians, The Magicians Alliance of the Eastern States and The International Brotherhood of Magicians have honored Stuart with 1st Place Awards for his Magic and Comedy. In September of 1997, The Magician Alliance of the Eastern States awarded him the Clint Riedel Trophy for "Best Act of the Competition 1997," their top award.

In June of 2001, The Society of American Magicians, Assembly #4 in Philadelphia, PA presented Stuart with the Charles H. Hopkins Award, the highest award given by this assembly. This award is given annually to a member of Assembly #4 who by his/her interest in magic most exemplifies the spirit of the late Charles H. Hopkins who was known for his outstanding contributions to the world of magic.